Entirely Unexpected Incredibly Delightful
$0.00 0 Open cart

YOUR FOOD BAG

Price
QTY

TOTAL

$0.00 Update cart

Price excludes delivery, which is applied at checkout. Orders will be processed in USD

Chocolates

76 products in collection

Grid view List view
Peppermint Meltaways
$5.00

Peppermint Meltaways

In stock
Mint and chocolate coalesce in the most refreshing treat this side of the Andes Mountains. Imagine the invigorating cool mint of a festive candy cane mixed with the silky smoothness of handmade chocolate converging in a cascade...
Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Meltaways
$5.00

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Meltaways

In stock
We always hear about how desirable it is to find chocolate that melts in your mouth, not in your hands - but what about a classic blend combining smooth chocolate with a creamy peanut buttery center that...
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Meltaways
$5.00

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Meltaways

In stock
We always hear about how desirable it is to find chocolate that melts in your mouth, not in your hands - but what about a classic blend combining smooth chocolate with a creamy peanut buttery center that...
Double Peanut Butter Meltaways
$5.00

Double Peanut Butter Meltaways

In stock
Better make it a double! What’s better than peanut butter? More peanut butter! We coated our special blend of peanut butter with our peanut butter chocolate to create what might be the peanuttiest treat out there. Too...
Milk Chocolate Salted Caramel Meltaways
$5.00

Milk Chocolate Salted Caramel Meltaways

In stock
Science has long since stated that sweet and salty just go together - and who are we to argue with science? Our Salted Caramel Meltaways offer further proof that these flavors just complement each other so, while...
Dark Chocolate Strawberry Meltaways
$5.00

Dark Chocolate Strawberry Meltaways

In stock
Pure Bliss! There is no better description for the silky smooth strawberry center surrounded by decadent dark chocolate. The perfect combination of fruit and chocolate is sure to be the little taste of happiness you need to...
Chocolate Turkey Lollipops
$10.00

Chocolate Turkey Lollipops

In stock
With four 1 ounce chocolate turkeys on a stick, our Chocolate Turkey Lollipops are sure to get gobbled up at first sight!
Chocolate-Covered Popcorn - 6 ounces
$10.00

Chocolate-Covered Popcorn - 6 ounces

In stock

A Sugar Plum staple, our chocolate-covered popcorn is delicately air-popped for perfect kernels and then lightly tossed in sea salt and olive oil for an unmatched flavor, all before being drizzled with our carefully-crafted milk and dark...

Chocolate-Covered Chips - 1/2 Pound
$11.00

Chocolate-Covered Chips - 1/2 Pound

In stock

Exclusively using the freshest locally-sourced Pennsylvania-made potato chips available, each one of our chocolate-covered chips is hand-dipped by our artisan chocolatiers to ensure that every bite provides the perfect balance between salty & crunchy chip and sweet...

Valentine’s Day Cuddle Bear Chocolate Lollipops
$13.00

Valentine’s Day Cuddle Bear Chocolate Lollipops

In stock

Featuring three of the most cuddly 2oz chocolate bears that you’ve ever seen in each lollipop, Sugar Plum’s Cuddle Bear Valentine’s Day Chocolate Lollipops are a perfect little treat for anyone on your special valentine’s list this year!