Can Orders Be Shipped To US Territories & International Destinations?

We ship to most U.S. territories and international locations. If your destination isn’t listed or you need assistance with your order, our customer service team is here to help at (800) 447-8427.

When Will My Order Arrive?

For standard shipping your order will arrive within 2-7 business days. Overnight delivery will arrive the next business day as long as your order has been placed by 2pm Eastern Standard Time.

Do Your Products Contain Allergens?

All of our products are manufactured in a facility that may also contain tree nuts, peanuts and soy.

Are Your Chocolates Kosher?

Some of our products are Kosher Certified. If a product is Kosher it will have the Kosher label.

How Should I Store My Chocolates?

The most favorable storage temperature for our chocolate products is between 60 and 68 degrees Fahrenheit. The product should also be stored in a cool and dry place. If stored under the proper conditions, our products will retain their freshness for months.

Does SugarPlum Offer Wedding Or Customized Flavors?

Sugar Plum can create favor boxes and personalized gifts for most any occasion. Please contact our support team at csr@sugar-plum.com.

What Is The Return Policy?

Due to the food-based nature of our products, Sugar Plum does not accept any returns of our products. All sales are final.

Nostalgic Chocolate Bars – 6 Pack | Custom Childhood Flavors

Bring back fond childhood memories with Sugar Plum’s Nostalgic Chocolate Bars – 6 Pack! Handcrafted with premium ingredients and inspired by beloved comfort foods, these 3.5 oz candy bars deliver a sweet taste of nostalgia in every bite.

Create your own personalized 6-pack by selecting your favorite flavors — or mix and match to try them all! Whether you're snacking, sharing, or gifting, these nostalgic chocolate bars offer a delicious trip down memory lane.

Choose from Six Nostalgic Flavors:

Apple Pie: Smooth milk chocolate with cinnamon, dried fruit chunks, and sea salt — the cozy taste of fall in every bite.
Pancakes & Syrup: A breakfast lover’s dream with milk and dark chocolate, vanilla wafers, and a sweet maple syrup flavor.
Peanut Butter & Jelly: Creamy milk chocolate infused with the nostalgic flavor of PB&J sandwiches.
Fruity Flake Bars: White fudge chocolate packed with fruity cereal pieces for a fun Saturday morning throwback.
Milk and Cookies: A comforting blend of milk chocolate, cookie pieces, and chocolate chips for the ultimate snack.
Cinnamon Roll: Silky white chocolate with cinnamon and sweet glaze flavors — like biting into a fresh sticky bun.

Key Features:

Handcrafted Nostalgic Flavors: Each bar brings back sweet memories with comforting, childhood-inspired flavors.
Choose Your Perfect 6-Pack: Mix and match your favorite flavors for a personalized chocolate experience.
Indulgent & Fun: Rich, creamy chocolate combined with playful, nostalgic flavors like Fruity Flakes and PB&J.
Perfect for Gifting & Sharing: A delicious and thoughtful gift for birthdays, holidays, care packages, or simply treating yourself.
Premium Ingredients: Crafted in small batches using high-quality chocolate and ingredients for the best flavor and texture.

Ideal For:

Chocolate Lovers: Indulge in creative, comforting chocolate flavors you won't find anywhere else.
Gift Giving: Perfect for birthdays, holidays, thank-you gifts, and more.
Fun Snacking: Add a playful twist to movie nights, celebrations, or everyday treats.
Building Gourmet Gift Baskets: Add a sweet, nostalgic touch to your next gift set.

Order Sugar Plum’s customizable Nostalgic Chocolate Bars 6-Pack today and savor the sweet memories — one delicious bite at a time!