Chocolate-Covered Peanut Butter Cookies - Gift Box of 12
Some chocolate and snack items are sensitive to heat. Enter your delivery ZIP code and we’ll check if cold-pack protection is recommended for your area.
Cold-pack protection helps reduce heat exposure during transit, especially for warmer states and summer deliveries.
Indulgent Add-Ons
Indulge in the ultimate sweet snack with our 12 Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies. Sugar Plum takes the classic flavor duo of creamy PB and spreads it between crisp crackers. Each treat is handcrafted to create a decadent confection that satisfies every craving.
Treat yourself to a midday pick-me-up or order if you're searching for a gourmet gift. Our Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies are sure to impress. Each box contains 12 individually wrapped crackers. The sweets will stay fresh and are easy to share or take on the go!
What’s Inside the Box:
12 Handcrafted Cookies:
A full dozen of our signature chocolate-covered peanut butter cracker cookies.
Individually Wrapped:
Every single sweet is packaged for peak freshness and provides convenient, mess-free snacking.
Why Order Them:
Perfect Balance of Sweet, Creamy, and Crunchy
We spread savory peanut butter between two crackers to handcraft sandwich cookies. Then, we hand-dip the snacks in silky milk chocolate.
Ultimate Convenience
Share these individually wrapped treats, bring them to the office, or enjoy on the go.
Woman-Owned Family Company Since 1995:
With over 30 years in the chocolate business, we guarantee "a little taste of happiness."
Newstalgic: Timeless Classic Flavors Handcrafted in a Contemporary Snack
Peanut butter, milk, chocolate, and two crackers create a delightful sandwich cookie. You will not find sweets with this quality level in a grocery store.
Suits All Occasions!
- Everyday Snacking • Personal or Corporate Gifting • Family Sharing •
Satisfy your cravings today! Order your 12-piece box of Sugar Plum's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies. Savor the ultimate sweet, creamy, and crunchy indulgence, one wrapped bite at a time.
Pairs Well With
Free Shipping On Orders Over $75
Gift Boxed & Ready to Impress
Handcrafted & Packed in PA
Couldn't load pickup availability
Pickup available at Sugar Plum Chocolates Warehouse
Usually ready in 24 hoursChocolate-Covered Peanut Butter Cookies - Gift Box of 12
Made For Moments That Truly Matter
Whether You’re Gifting Or Indulging, Our Handcrafted Treats Are Designed To Elevate Every Occasion. Thoughtfully Made, Beautifully Packed, And Ever Satisfying.
Everyday Indulgence Done Better
Everyday Indulgence Done Better
Noticeably Better Chocolate
Richer, smoother, and more refined than everyday treats, crafted for a deeper, more satisfying bite
Effortless, Thoughtful Gifting
Beautifully presented and carefully curated, making it easy to send something premium and genuinely appreciated
Flavors Worth Slowing Down For
From classic favorites to indulgent creations, each piece is designed with balance, texture, and depth
Crafted Over Decades
Over 30 years of experience focused on consistency, quality ingredients, and chocolates people return for
More Than Just A Gift, It’s The Joy You Share
Product FAQs
Can Orders Be Shipped To US Territories & International Destinations?
We ship to most U.S. territories and international locations. If your destination isn’t listed or you need assistance with your order, our customer service team is here to help at (800) 447-8427.
What If My Order Was Shipped To The Incorrect Address?
If the error was made by Sugar Plum Chocolates then we will refund or re-ship the item to the customer at no cost. Unfortunately, if the address was entered incorrectly by the customer during checkout Sugar Plum Chocolates is not responsible.
When Will My Order Arrive?
For standard shipping your order will arrive within 2-7 business days.
Overnight delivery will arrive the next business day as long as your order has been placed by 2pm Eastern Standard Time.
Do Your Products Contain Allergens?
All of our products are manufactured in a facility that may also contain tree nuts, peanuts and soy.
Are Your Chocolates Kosher?
Some of our products are Kosher Certified. If a product is Kosher it will have the Kosher label.
How Should I Store My Chocolates?
The most favorable storage temperature for our chocolate products is between 60 and 68 degrees Fahrenheit. The product should also be stored in a cool and dry place.
If stored under the proper conditions, our products will retain their freshness for months.
Does SugarPlum Offer Wedding Or Customized Flavors?
Sugar Plum can create favor boxes and personalized gifts for most any occasion. Please contact our support team at csr@sugar-plum.com.
What Is The Return Policy?
Due to the food-based nature of our products, Sugar Plum does not accept any returns of our products. All sales are final.