Entirely Unexpected Incredibly Delightful

YOUR FOOD BAG


Price
QTY

TOTAL

$0.00 Update cart

Price excludes delivery, which is applied at checkout. Orders will be processed in USD

Valentine's Day

13 products in collection

Strawberry Cheesecake Chocolate Bar - 4-Pack
$30.00

Strawberry Cheesecake Chocolate Bar - 4-Pack

In stock

The best of both worlds! Creamy and indulgent strawberry cheesecake in a melt-in-your-mouth chocolate bar. Imagine biting into a fluffy cloud of creamy cheesecake, except this cheesecake isn’t a cake at all, but rather a decadent chocolate...

Chocolate Heart Pizza
$35.00

Chocolate Heart Pizza

In stock

Our Chocolate Heart Pizza is a unique treat that you are simply bound to fall head over heels for!

This solid milk chocolate heart is topped with a festive assortment of chocolate candies and finished with a white chocolate drizzle. ...

Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Sandwich Cookies - 20 Pieces
$35.00

Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Sandwich Cookies - 20 Pieces

Coming Soon
Featuring 20 of our world-class milk chocolate-dunked sandwich cookies, all drizzled in festive pink chocolate and beautifully laid out in a red-and-silver heart-shaped box that will set the mood for a fantastic day and...
Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Peanut Butter Cracker Cookies - 20 Pieces
$35.00

Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Peanut Butter Cracker Cookies - 20 Pieces

Coming Soon

Proven to be a winning combination for decades, the mix of chocolate and peanut butter is a blend that has a little bit of something for both the sweet tooth and salt fanatic...

Classic Valentine’s Day Heart Truffle Assortment - 24 Pieces
$35.00

Classic Valentine’s Day Heart Truffle Assortment - 24 Pieces

Coming Soon

For those that prefer to be the classic romantic with a truffle assortment this Valentine’s Day, look no further than Sugar Plum’s Classic Valentine’s Day Heart Truffle Assortment!  

This assortment features a 24-piece assortment of...

Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Toffee - 1 Pound
$35.00

Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Toffee - 1 Pound

Coming Soon

Carefully crafted each and every batch by the hands of our Sugar Plum artisans, our Valentine’s Day Milk Chocolate-Covered Toffee is a sweet, savory, and scrumptious treat that simply needs to be tasted...

Wine Truffle Box Assortment
$35.00

Wine Truffle Box Assortment

In stock

For those that want to be a little more fun with a truffle assortment look no further than Sugar Plum’s Wine Box Truffle Assortment! 

This assortment features a 12-piece assortment of Sugar Plum’s incredible handcrafted chocolate truffles all beautifully...

Beer & Bourbon Liquor Nuts Gift Tin  - 16oz
$30.00

Beer & Bourbon Liquor Nuts Gift Tin - 16oz

In stock

Addicting and sweet, but not too sweet!

Sugar Plum's very adult take on classic Beer and Bourbon Liquor Nuts Gift Tin will have everyone thanking you and craving more. This 16 ounce assortment of our mouth-watering, hand-crafted, and small-batch...

Beer and Bourbon Flavored Peanuts 3-Pack
$15.00

Beer and Bourbon Flavored Peanuts 3-Pack

Coming Soon

Ever look for a snack that you can just go nuts for?

We sure have, which is why we've locked ourselves away into our test labs until our mad scientists were able to make nuts so potent you'd swear...

Chocolate-Covered Pretzels - Box of 12
$20.00

Chocolate-Covered Pretzels - Box of 12

In stock

Using our location to our advantage & choosing only the freshest and finest in Pennsylvania-made pretzels, our chocolate-covered pretzels present a unique blend of crunchiness, saltiness, sweetness, and savoriness that stands uncontested against all chocolate-covered confections.